In 2009, there are four nominated plays competing for top honors at the Tony Awards. Two comedies and two dramas. Reasons To Be Pretty, which leans more towards a comedy than the dramatic event, is Neil LaBute's first Tony nomination as well as his Broadway debut. The other two dramas, 33 Variations and Dividing The Estate, had strong leading ladies, large ensambles but tend to lack the depth needed for working modern drama. The last nominee, a play adapted by Christopher Hampton from a French tex by Yasmina Reza, is God of Carnage. It was originally staged in Zurich in December of 2006, and has been honored with the Olivier award this year for Best Play.GOC, as it will thus forward be noted as, has an all star cast featuring Jeff Daniels, Marcia Gay Harden, James Gandolfini, and Hope Davis. The four give equally compelling performances though Harden stands out. The story focuses around two couples being brought together in hope of reconciling the relationship of their children. Daniels and Davis vs. Harden and Gandolfini match wits in a 90 minute confrontation that oftens finds each character siding with either their opponent or their opponents partner. The characters rarely exhibit forms of cliches and stereotypes are avoided completely. The music that opens and closes the play adds a feeling of savagery to a work that at its center focuses on just that.
There are gags in this play that tickle the audience, such as Hope Davis vomiting over Harden's coffee table filled with priceless art and photography books. However, the real laughs, as they should, come from the silence. Gandolfini has showed a complete turn from his Sopranos role on HBO and exhibits a calm, almost Zen-like character. His silence and digression towards his wife speaks volumes than when dialogue is uttered. The poetry that Reza writes with cannot be denied. However, the intelligence levels on some of the characters doesn't seem to match their vocabularies.
As the fighting comes to an end, or what we feel is somewhat of an end, the conflict still remains in the air. This, however, is not a play where are invited on a journey that will resolved by the end of the night. Reza and Hampton invite us to look at the human condition, to see it for what it is. The dramatization of bringing us into a "Virginia Woolf" type of night works for most of the evening. However, unlike the impact of Albee's work, we are left here to only laugh at ourselves in the end. We can conclude that we are children our entire lives fighting battles that we, in the end, have no desire to win. The direction is impressive, as well as the vibrant red and other worldly set. Of the few comedies that advertise themselves as comedies, and not the next best American drama, GOC delights. You will laugh, and laugh hard. In an age where we scream at the author for allowing others to bicker on stage and call it conflict, Reza shouts back at us. She lets us know that a screaming match with rising conflict can work. As is the view of Sarah Ruhl, why not play the subtext? Let us, the audience, hear exactly what you feel. Maybe we don't know why you feel it, but the fact that you feel it is reason enough. In GOC, we have the characters we hate and the characters we love. The enlightening experience is, at one time or another, we love and hate them all.


